You Can See Everything
20 October 2026
Nancy!
First off, thank you so much for taking the time to share your thoughts with a Total Stranger. But now we are Friends, or at least Friendly Acquaintances, and I am eager to discuss both your email and the documentary in equal measure.
I followed Holmes from the beginning of her media career. I read the first articles, touting her as an Exceptional Young Woman, and the Future of Science. I am neither exceptional, nor the future, and my grasp of science is…limited. But I am fascinated by people who either present themselves as genius, or are presented as genius, because I think it says more about our time and our understanding of words than it does about the “achievements” of the engeniused.
And then, because I am perverse, I read with even more joy — and some schadenfreude — everything about her downfall. The machines that didn’t work. The businesses that were duped. The investors who invested Too Much and got back Too Little. I read (well, listened to) the (audio)book, Bad Blood. I read reviews of the book Bad Blood. I read interviews with poor George Shultz’s grandson, one of the whistleblowers.
So I came to the documentary a little poised to dislike Holmes. But I think I also had something of a leery open mind. I only know what I have read about Holmes. And what I have read about Holmes came from other people. I do not know everything. (I still do not.) I was going to give her as much of a chance as I could.
I left the documentary feeling that I know the same amount as I knew going in — only more intensified. I will admit to thinking (maybe even hoping) that I was going to leave it with Holmes somewhat rehabilitated in my eyes. “Maybe she isn’t as bad as we have made her out to be! Maybe she’s a victim of the System!” — that “System!” being maybe misogyny or patriarchy or both, probably both — “Maybe we can like her!”
It felt as if that was the direction the documentary was going. The first time I noticed you reacting at the same place I was reacting was in the scrambled eggs scene, where Billy takes the bowl from her, and lies about why he took it. “I just want her to have an undistracted conversation with you,” he says to Nathan Fielder. But Holmes immediately says, “No, he hates the way I stir eggs. I ruin them, because I don’t stir enough.” And so later, when she tries to suggest that she doesn’t lie — doesn’t even really understand the concept of lying; why on earth would she or anyone lie; what even is lying? — I jumped immediately back to those eggs and thought, “She’s a goddamned liar who lies.”
Amanda Seyfried showing up was shocking to me, in the most delightful way, like a spoonful of sugar, after some of the bitterness of watching Billy and “Liz” (I just don’t see her as a “Liz” by the way) be a family together. But, like you, I sort of tired of her. But I think she is a necessary component of the movie. So much depends, like rain on a wheelbarrow near white chickens, on that New York Times quote (or misquote) about a character someone else created, or Elizabeth Holmes created. Seeing someone who had created a character out of what she knew of Holmes was perfectly shocking. Watching Seyfried start out defending Holmes as someone being manipulated by a romantic partner, to the sudden(ish) sea change to believing that Holmes is manipulating everyone else is necessary. This whole idea of who has Holmes correct is a key part of the documentary. One of my favorite writers, Hilary Mantel, in a lecture series she gave back in 2017, says, “As soon as we die, we enter into fiction.” But I think that happens much sooner than death. As soon as we pass out of the presence of another person, that person translates us into fiction. They have to, in a sense. I have no doubt done it to you. I know who you are in a specific circumstance. But I do not know you the way others, more intimately connected to you, do. And they do not know you at all, really, either. They know enough of you to create a simulacrum, and because they love you, they have created it lovingly.
The thing the documentary has left me with — at least at this time — is the sense that everyone is a cipher, and the strength of our relationships depends on the trust we can put into that cipher. Elizabeth Holmes, at the end of the documentary, did not leave me feeling as if we have misunderstood her. But it did leave me feeling that she doesn’t at all understand herself. She is instead willing — almost eager — to let others work their marionettes with her painted face. It’s plausible deniability, and I think it’s what allows her to face herself every day, after what she has done, which is bilk people out of trust and money and, in some cases, their health.
I think I will watch this movie probably three more times — especially now that I know what the structure is, and I can pay more attention to what I want to pay attention to. I think there are definite gaps in what I wanted the documentary to do — but that’s maybe not the fault of the documentary. (I think you are right when you say they were “beyond the scope of focus of the film on the personalities of Elizabeth and Billy.”) Things that I would have loved to see, though:
- A much longer conversation with Elizabeth’s father, who knows exactly what Billy is up to, because he saw it with Sunny.
- Maybe some interviews with the whistleblowers — especially if he could also show them drafts of the documentary he had available.
- A conversation with Holmes, similar to the one he had with her about the “Who’s On First?” joke (by the way, my husband does not understand why that joke is funny either; however, he also isn’t in a federal prison camp for unethical behavior), where he asks her to Steelman the arguments against her. “Why do you think you are going to prison?” Maybe that happens a little in the documentary, now that I think about it. Maybe he asks her and she just says, with her terrifyingly opened eyes, “I don’t know.” But maybe pushing her to guess would be interesting. Or infuriating.
And I have written far too much, and also not enough, but I will draw this email to a close. Any other thoughts you have, I would love to hear. And I will definitely write to you again after I see the Elon Musk documentary.
Regards,
M