Histories 1.1-94 Wrap Up
On the walk to the bus-stop, and on the bus ride home, I kept thinking about Herodotus, religion, and fate. What follows are my disorganized thoughts that only look organized because I know where to put a paragraph, and how semicolons work. Test everything in this essay that sounds suspect. Especially test things in this essay that sound true. Making things sound true is how they get you.
One of my opening questions for the group today (it is a cold but beautiful Saturday on October 17, 2026) was to think about how Herodotus’s geographical location might affect his treatment of his subject. Herodotus tells us he wants to accomplish a few things by sharing his reporting — ἱστορίης or historiē: He wants to explain why the Greeks and the Persians went to war; and, key to my essay, he wants to share the accomplishments of both Greeks and non-Greeks — what he calls βαρβάροισι.
My argument — or, rather, my strongly-held though not-tested hypothesis — is that, because Herodotus is a Greek living outside of Greece, he has a multicultural perception of the world around him. Not only is Herodotus living outside of Greece, he is living within the Persian empire, in a Greek colony. To see the extraordinary Persian achievements would not be as difficult for someone positioned in the way Herodotus is positioned. They are, essentially, in his neighborhood.
There are many ways of telling a story. The most effective, I find, is when the teller has a stake. It is the difference between telling your story, and having your story told to you. Herodotus will not be sharing the details of Persian successful exploits from a distance. He is sharing them from within the dominant culture of where he lives; and he is sharing these exploits to the dominant culture where he does not live.
So far, religion seems to be the dominant way a society defines itself. There have been attempts at an agnostic, or even atheistic, way of organizing a society — but what appears to be the most successful (while remembering that just because something succeeds does not make it right) are societies that form around a common religious practice. And because of this, Herodotus finds himself in something of a bind.
Greek religion is organized around a series of gods. There are the Olympian gods — Zeus, Hera, Poseidon, Demeter, Athena, Apollo, Artemis, Ares, Aphrodite, Hephaestus, Hermes, and Hestia (or Dionysus). There are Titans, the generation before the Olympians: Kronos, Oceanus, Hyperion, Iapetus, Coeus, Crius, Rhea, Themis, Mnemosyne, Theia, Phoebe, and Tethys. And there are the Primordials: Gaia, Uranus, Tartarus, Eros, Nyx, and Erebus. But above all of these, it would seem, is Fate. In Greek religion, there is no code of right and wrong. Instead, religion works itself into and out of knots via Divine Drama. While the gods were never arbiters of correct behavior, there were correct and incorrect ways to offer obeisance and tribute to the various deities. However, the stories about the gods — the “Just So” tales, to drag a Kipling idea into the deep past — functioned as descriptions of the way different behaviors worked their way out. Others were etiological: why do spiders weave? Why does the narcissus flower grow where it grows?
Persian religion (either Zoroastrianism or Mazdaism) is dualistic. There isn’t a divine family of several generations. There is Ahura Mazda (the Wise Lord) and his wicked counter, Angra Mainyu. The world is because these two are.
(Please understand how un-nuanced my descriptions are here — both because I want to make a specific point, which I am getting to; but also because Persian religion cannot be summed up helpfully in a paragraph, let alone a single essay.)
Herodotus is a man, living in a society structured around dualism: Ahura Mazda and his battle against Angra Mainyu. But he is of a society with a rich, dramatic pantheon of gods. And, rather than taking a side; rather than asserting that the Olympian gods (and the Titans, when it is helpful, and the Primordials, when you need something really old with your borrowed and blue) are primary, if not solitary, arbiters of religious life; Herodotus takes an agnostic middle way, while quietly stripping much of the mythological out of his reporting. And I think only someone in that liminal space Herodotus inhabits could effectively and honestly do that delicate threading.
The sense I get — especially by the time we reach chapter 94 of Book 1 — is that deity is not as important to Herodotus as much as Fate, with a Capital F, is. Fate is the step on which any person must fall down, or else o’erleap, for in our way it lies. Is it a god, God, free will, or Fate that puts Croesus in his place again, and again, and oh my god AGAIN?? Can Fate be outrun? The ranking seems to follow this flow:
Fate (above everything)
↓
Gods (above humans, but subservient to Fate)
↓
Humans (ultimately subservient to Fate; often attempt to appeal to the gods to intervene within a system that the gods may not be able to control in the first place)
What we may find, in the pages and pages of Herodotus’s Histories that we will read together, is that Fate is inescapable, gods are good scapegoats, and regardless of what we’ll do and we’ll do and we’ll do — it must align with what has been predestined for us. Suffering comes from not accepting what was already written down for us in the Book of Life.